Lewis-Skelly Deal Out Of The Closet

There are certain players who are supposed to be different.

Myles Lewis-Skelly should be one of them.

The 19-year-old has been at Arsenal since childhood, came through Hale End alongside best mate Ethan Nwaneri and, when his opportunity arrived, looked as though he had been playing Premier League football for years.

A midfielder by trade, Lewis-Skelly was thrown in at left-back and barely blinked. He was aggressive, technically excellent and remarkably composed. Within months, he had gone from academy prospect to Premier League champion and Champions League finalist.

This is exactly how it is supposed to work.

A kid comes through the academy, gets his chance, grabs it and becomes part of the furniture. Supporters watch him develop knowing that, unlike the latest £70million arrival, this one really is theirs.

Except modern football has a nasty habit of ruining nice stories.

Arsenal are not actively trying to sell Lewis-Skelly. The player himself has no desire to leave. And yet, remarkably, that doesn’t necessarily mean he will still be at the Emirates when the transfer window closes.

Welcome to football in 2026.

Mikel Arteta’s side have already spent £75million on Bruno Guimaraes and added Christos Tzolis, while further defensive and attacking reinforcements are expected before the window shuts.

Winning the Premier League has not persuaded Arsenal to stand still. Quite the opposite. They want to establish themselves as England’s dominant force and finally get their hands on the Champions League.

That costs money.

And somewhere behind the scenes, while supporters debate whether Arsenal need another winger or centre-back, people with calculators and frighteningly complicated spreadsheets are making sure everything adds up.

This is where Lewis-Skelly suddenly becomes uncomfortable.

As an academy graduate, any transfer fee received for him represents almost entirely pure accounting profit. Sell a player bought for £50million for £60million and the financial benefit isn’t necessarily enormous once his remaining book value is considered. Sell a Hale End graduate for £60million and the numbers look considerably prettier.

Chelsea and Manchester United have both been linked with Lewis-Skelly and Arsenal’s position appears to be that they are not inviting bids — but they might listen if somebody makes one sufficiently ridiculous.

That is an important distinction.

Arsenal don’t want to sell him.

Lewis-Skelly doesn’t want to leave.

But neither statement contains the words “not for sale”.

And that is the problem.

Because Lewis-Skelly should be about as close to untouchable as it gets.

He is 19. He is already good enough to play regularly for the Premier League champions. He can operate in midfield or defence. He understands Arsenal, loves Arsenal and represents something supporters desperately want to believe still matters.

Three months ago he started a Champions League final.

If that doesn’t earn a teenager a giant metaphorical KEEP OFF sign around his neck, what does?

There is also a danger Arsenal should not underestimate.

Football supporters will accept an awful lot in the name of progress. They accept ticket-price rises, ludicrous kick-off times and favourite players being moved on because somebody younger and shinier has become available.

But academy players occupy slightly different territory.

Bukayo Saka isn’t merely one of Arsenal’s best players because of what he does on the pitch. He represents the connection between club and supporter. Lewis-Skelly and Nwaneri have the potential to become part of the same tradition.

You cannot spend years talking about Hale End, celebrate these players when they break through and then treat them as particularly convenient entries on an accounting spreadsheet the moment financial regulations start becoming awkward.

Of course, Arsenal could argue that this is simply the reality of competing at the very top.

Perhaps it is.

If somebody offered £80million for Lewis-Skelly and that money allowed Arsenal to sign a world-class attacker who delivered another Premier League title and the Champions League, plenty of supporters would eventually forgive them.

Probably.

Football fans are remarkably flexible when trophies start appearing.

But it would still leave a sour taste.

And there is an uncomfortable question about how Arsenal reached this point in the first place.

Should the financial rules be changed because they effectively encourage clubs to sell their own academy products? Almost certainly.

But Arsenal knew those rules existed before committing £75million to Guimaraes and embarking on another ambitious summer of recruitment.

You cannot complain about the rules only after doing the shopping.

Maybe this all comes to nothing. Maybe Lewis-Skelly starts Arsenal’s opening game of the season and remains at the Emirates for the next decade. Hopefully he does.

But the fact this conversation is even taking place tells us something slightly depressing about modern football.

Here is a brilliant 19-year-old academy graduate who loves Arsenal.

Arsenal love him.

The supporters love him.

He doesn’t want to leave.

The club doesn’t particularly want to sell him.

And somehow, despite all of that, he could still end up somewhere else because the numbers on a spreadsheet say it makes sense.

Sometimes football really does make things much more complicated than they need to be.

Double Deal For Teenage Duo

Arsenal have reportedly agreed a deal to sign Crystal Palace youngster Mylo Bernard on a training compensation deal, according to The Athletic.

The Gunners are once again dipping into the academy market, with Premier League clubs increasingly targeting young players from rival academies before they have the chance to put pen to paper on professional contracts.

Arsenal have already raided north London rivals Tottenham this summer for Elijah Upson, and Bernard now looks set to become the latest highly rated youngster to make the move to the Emirates.

For clubs like Palace, these situations are becoming increasingly frustrating.

Academies can spend years developing young players, only for a Premier League rival to swoop in when their schoolboy registration expires. Without a professional contract in place, there is little a club can do to prevent a player from moving on, with the buying club instead paying a relatively small training compensation fee.

That appears to be exactly what has happened with Bernard.

According to The Athletic, Arsenal have agreed a deal to sign the 16-year-old forward from Crystal Palace this summer. His schoolboy registration has expired, allowing him to leave Palace and join Arsenal on a training compensation deal.

And this isn’t simply a case of Arsenal signing an unknown academy player.

Bernard is an England Under-16 international and primarily operates as a centre-forward, although he is also capable of playing on either wing. Despite his age, he was already getting opportunities with Palace’s Under-18s last season.

He certainly made his mark.

Bernard scored a second-half hat-trick as Palace’s Under-18s came from behind to beat Reading 4-2, underlining the kind of attacking potential that has apparently caught Arsenal’s attention.

The Gunners have made no secret of their desire to build a strong academy pipeline, and signing players like Bernard is another example of that strategy in action.

From Palace’s perspective, however, it will be a frustrating outcome. They have helped develop a young England international who was already playing above his age group, only to see him potentially walk away before the club could secure him on professional terms.

For Arsenal, though, this is precisely the sort of opportunity they will be looking to exploit.

Bernard is only 16, so there is obviously a long way to go before anyone can say whether he will eventually make the grade at senior level. But an England Under-16 international already competing with an Under-18 side and scoring hat-tricks is certainly enough to suggest there is plenty to work with.

Arsenal will hope they’ve found another academy gem.

Palace will simply hope the next one doesn’t get away.

Sent from my iPhone

Another Pre-Season Defeat - Don’t Panic!

Arsenal’s defeat reveals the tantalising possibilities of Arteta’s new midfield

Just under three months after that unforgettable night in May, Arsenal returned to the Emirates Stadium as Premier League champions.

There was no trophy to lift this time and no victory to celebrate. Borussia Dortmund won an entertaining pre-season friendly 3-2, exposing some of the rustiness that has characterised Arsenal’s preparations. Yet the afternoon still offered a glimpse of why there is so much excitement about the season ahead.

Before kick-off, Bruno Guimaraes walked onto the pitch for the first time as an Arsenal player, greeted by a booming chorus of “Bruno!” from the home support.

It was a moment Arsenal supporters had waited a long time to see. Four and a half years after the club decided against signing him from Lyon, Guimaraes has finally arrived—and he joins a midfield overflowing with possibilities.

Mikel Arteta highlighted the Brazilian’s versatility, ball-winning instincts, speed of progression and ability to break into the penalty area. In other words, Arsenal have not signed a specialist. They have acquired a midfielder capable of changing his role according to the opposition and the players around him.

That flexibility could prove invaluable.

Guimaraes can operate as the deepest midfielder, but restricting him to a conventional holding role would waste some of his best qualities. He can win possession, escape pressure, accelerate attacks and arrive late in the box. He is aggressive without the ball and adventurous with it.

The intriguing question is not simply where Guimaraes plays. It is what his arrival allows Arsenal’s other midfielders to become.

Martin Odegaard provided a partial answer on Sunday.

The Arsenal captain was given only 30 minutes following his post-World Cup holiday, but immediately brought greater imagination to a team that had struggled to play through Dortmund with any fluency.

Odegaard threaded passes behind the defence for Viktor Gyokeres, Kai Havertz and Max Dowman to chase. He was secure when Arsenal needed control and incisive when an opportunity presented itself. Brief though his appearance was, he looked much more like the player who illuminated the World Cup with Norway than the one who sometimes struggled to impose himself during the earlier stages of last season.

How Arteta deploys him will be fascinating.

During Arsenal’s title run-in, Odegaard was often pushed into a more advanced No 10 position, combining with Eberechi Eze around the penalty area. For Norway, however, he excelled in a deeper and more energetic role, collecting possession earlier and dictating the game from the centre.

Guimaraes gives Arteta the freedom to use either version.

Arsenal could field Guimaraes at the base with Odegaard and Eze ahead of him. They could use a more balanced double pivot, allowing Odegaard to begin deeper before advancing into attacking areas. Against particularly physical opponents, Guimaraes could play further forward and lead Arsenal’s press.

There will be no shortage of tactical diagrams produced over the next few weeks. The encouraging thing is that Arsenal’s midfield no longer appears dependent on one fixed formula.

Tzolis makes his case

If Arsenal’s midfield supplied the intrigue, their wingers provided the urgency.

Dowman and Christos Tzolis have started throughout pre-season and may be required again when Arsenal face Manchester City in next Sunday’s Community Shield.

The continued emergence of Dowman is becoming almost absurd. He is still only 16, yet he looks increasingly comfortable playing against senior opposition. His intelligent touches and sudden bursts behind Maximilian Beier repeatedly altered the shape of Arsenal’s attacks.

He created an early opportunity for Gyokeres, who struck the crossbar, and won a free kick inches outside the penalty area. These were the moments when Dowman looked most liberated—receiving the ball, committing his defender and playing without fear.

Tzolis took longer to become involved but eventually became Arsenal’s most influential attacker.

The Greek international’s game is refreshingly uncomplicated. He receives the ball and immediately looks to beat his opponent, shoot or deliver into the penalty area. There is very little sterile possession for its own sake.

With Arsenal trailing 2-0, Tzolis drove into the Dortmund box and sent a low left-footed cross towards Nwaneri, who reduced the deficit. He later won the penalty converted by Gyokeres.

Bukayo Saka, Noni Madueke and Eze are due to return to training on Monday, but none has enjoyed a proper pre-season. If Arteta decides they are not ready to begin the campaign, Dowman and Tzolis have done enough to merit serious consideration.

Tzolis, in particular, looks capable of offering something Arsenal occasionally lacked last season: directness. He does not merely occupy the width; he uses it as a platform from which to attack.

Pre-season errors—or warning signs?

The less encouraging aspect of Arsenal’s afternoon was the defending.

Dortmund established a two-goal lead through Samuele Inacio and Konstantino Karetsas. After Nwaneri pulled one back, Joane Gadou restored the visitors’ advantage before Gyokeres converted from the spot to complete the scoring.

Arsenal have now conceded six goals in consecutive defeats against Real Betis and Dortmund. Both performances have contained the kind of peculiar individual mistakes often dismissed as pre-season rust.

That explanation is reasonable—but only to a point.

Arsenal have lacked first-team regulars, while some of those who have played appear to be at very different stages of their preparation. Kepa Arrizabalaga has not covered himself in glory in David Raya’s absence, inevitably reopening the debate over whether Arsenal should retain him as second choice or place greater faith in new signing Illan Meslier.

My own view is that Meslier is the better goalkeeper, although plenty will disagree. Either way, Arsenal cannot afford uncertainty behind Raya if they intend to challenge on four fronts.

The problems have not been confined to the goalkeepers. Outfield players have waited for passes instead of meeting them, failed to anticipate pressure and approached defensive duels with a worrying lack of intensity.

Arteta was right to describe the goals as a collective responsibility. Arsenal’s defensive excellence has always depended upon the entire side reacting together. When the press is half-hearted or one player switches off, the structure quickly begins to look far less secure.

The good news is that Arteta will finally have his complete squad from Monday. Saka, Eze, Madueke and the remaining returning internationals should raise both the quality and intensity of training.

Wednesday’s friendly against Cesc Fabregas’s Como should therefore provide a more accurate indication of Arsenal’s condition before the Community Shield.

Nobody should lose sleep over a pre-season defeat. Dortmund looked sharper, Arsenal made mistakes and the result will soon be forgotten.

What may prove far more significant was the sight of Guimaraes standing on the Emirates pitch, Odegaard rediscovering his passing rhythm and Tzolis driving relentlessly at the Dortmund defence.

Arsenal still have plenty to sharpen. But beneath the rust, the shape of a frighteningly versatile team is beginning to emerge.

Sent from my iPhone

Brawny Bruno finally arrives at Arsenal

After a bit of a transfer saga, brawn sandwich Bruno Guimaraes is finally an Arsenal player, adding meat, gristle and strength to an already powerful midfield.

It has taken four and a half years, a Newcastle detour and considerably more money than it would have cost the first time around, but Arsenal have eventually got their man.

Back in January 2022, Edu and Tim Lewis had thrashed out a deal to bring Guimaraes to north London from Lyon. Mikel Arteta decided against it, reportedly unconvinced that the Brazilian was the right fit for the side he was constructing.

Newcastle United required considerably less persuasion.

They signed Guimaraes for around £40million and watched him develop into their captain, talisman and one of the Premier League’s most complete midfielders. Arsenal, meanwhile, were given regular opportunities to reconsider their decision as he fought, passed, tackled and occasionally quarrelled his way through a succession of fierce encounters with Arteta’s side.

Now, after paying Newcastle £75m, Arsenal have corrected their original mistake.

The Premier League champions confirmed on Saturday that Guimaraes had signed a four-year contract, with the option of another 12 months. There are no performance-related add-ons, although Lyon and the player’s former Brazilian clubs will receive portions of the fee.

This was not a transfer Newcastle wanted to sanction. Guimaraes meant more to them than his statistics or market value could adequately express. He was the captain around whom they intended to build their next team and a player who had developed a genuine connection with the city.

Their original demand of at least £100m was therefore understandable, even if Arsenal never appeared remotely interested in meeting it.

Arsenal’s opening offer was reportedly only £45m, which probably did little to improve relations between the clubs. Much of the subsequent negotiation was conducted through intermediary Kia Joorabchian rather than directly by sporting director Andrea Berta. Newcastle were frustrated by Arsenal’s apparent distance, while weeks passed without meaningful progress.

Arsenal were content to wait.

They knew Guimaraes wanted the move and believed Newcastle’s position would eventually soften as the end of the transfer window approached. The player had made it clear that he wanted to work with Arteta and personal terms were never a problem.

After the departures of Sandro Tonali to Tottenham and Anthony Gordon to Barcelona, Newcastle had been determined to retain their captain. However, Guimaraes’ desire to leave gradually made that position untenable.

Once he travelled directly to Spain rather than returning to England before Newcastle’s training camp, the transfer entered its decisive phase. A senior Newcastle executive finally contacted an Arsenal counterpart directly in an attempt to bring an end to what one source described as the “melodrama”.

Arsenal hoped to complete the deal for approximately £65m. Newcastle insisted £75m was the minimum acceptable figure. Eventually, the champions paid it.

For Arsenal, this is an outstanding signing.

Guimaraes can operate as either a No 6 or No 8, giving Arteta numerous midfield combinations. He is press-resistant, aggressive and capable of advancing the ball through both his passing and movement. He also possesses the slightly nasty competitive streak that every successful team needs.

Declan Rice apparently welcomed him with the message: “Come here and please no more fights, now we’re friends.”

That rather neatly captures why opposing supporters frequently dislike Guimaraes while wishing he played for their own team.

At 28—he turns 29 in November—the Brazilian sits outside Arsenal’s usual recruitment profile. That should not be considered a serious concern. Arsenal are no longer assembling a young team in the hope that it might eventually challenge for the title. They are Premier League champions attempting to remain champions.

There comes a point when potential has to be supplemented by experience, authority and players ready to deliver immediately.

The departures of Leandro Trossard and Christian Norgaard have also reduced the age of the squad. Gabriel Jesus remains available for transfer, while Mikel Merino, at 30, is currently Arsenal’s oldest outfield player. The squad can comfortably absorb an experienced midfielder at the peak of his career.

Indeed, Guimaraes may be precisely what Arsenal need.

The question is where everybody else fits.

Arteta now has an embarrassment of riches in central midfield. Rice, Guimaraes, Martin Odegaard, Martin Zubimendi, Merino and several younger options cannot all expect to start regularly.

Rice and Guimaraes could form a formidable partnership, with either capable of playing deeper or pushing forward. Guimaraes could also operate alongside Zubimendi, allowing Rice to take up the more advanced position in which he has become increasingly influential.

On paper, the possibilities are glorious. In practice, somebody is likely to find himself spending more time on the substitutes’ bench than expected.

That brings us to Zubimendi.

Reports continue to suggest that the Spaniard is homesick and open to returning to La Liga. His first season at Arsenal has not been a failure, but the arrival of Guimaraes inevitably raises further questions about his role.

Arsenal are unlikely to have invested £75m in Newcastle’s captain merely to improve the quality of their substitutes. Nor is Rice going anywhere. If Arteta intends to retain Odegaard as his principal creative midfielder, Zubimendi may suddenly find himself squeezed out of the preferred XI.

Perhaps Arteta wants genuine competition in every position. Perhaps he envisages rotating his midfield according to the opposition. Perhaps Zubimendi will adapt, flourish and make any discussion of a return to Spain irrelevant.

But the Guimaraes deal changes the equation.

For Newcastle, his departure closes the most significant chapter of their recent history. Guimaraes was visibly emotional when saying goodbye to his team-mates and staff, and nobody at the club has questioned his professionalism. Nevertheless, there is no disguising the scale of the loss.

New head coach Matthias Jaissle at least has £75m to reinvest and several weeks in which to do it. That is preferable to beginning the season with an unsettled captain or becoming trapped in the type of final-week scramble that followed Alexander Isak’s departure for Liverpool.

For Arsenal, this is another demonstration of their new status.

They once decided Bruno Guimaraes was not quite right for them. Four and a half years later, having watched him become one of the Premier League’s finest midfielders, they have paid £75m to bring him to the Emirates.

First impressions are not always final ones.

Guimaraes is finally an Arsenal player. The next question is whether his arrival will send Zubimendi back to Spain.

Sent from my iPhone