After a bit of a transfer saga, brawn sandwich Bruno Guimaraes is finally an Arsenal player, adding meat, gristle and strength to an already powerful midfield.
It has taken four and a half years, a Newcastle detour and considerably more money than it would have cost the first time around, but Arsenal have eventually got their man.
Back in January 2022, Edu and Tim Lewis had thrashed out a deal to bring Guimaraes to north London from Lyon. Mikel Arteta decided against it, reportedly unconvinced that the Brazilian was the right fit for the side he was constructing.
Newcastle United required considerably less persuasion.
They signed Guimaraes for around £40million and watched him develop into their captain, talisman and one of the Premier League’s most complete midfielders. Arsenal, meanwhile, were given regular opportunities to reconsider their decision as he fought, passed, tackled and occasionally quarrelled his way through a succession of fierce encounters with Arteta’s side.
Now, after paying Newcastle £75m, Arsenal have corrected their original mistake.
The Premier League champions confirmed on Saturday that Guimaraes had signed a four-year contract, with the option of another 12 months. There are no performance-related add-ons, although Lyon and the player’s former Brazilian clubs will receive portions of the fee.
This was not a transfer Newcastle wanted to sanction. Guimaraes meant more to them than his statistics or market value could adequately express. He was the captain around whom they intended to build their next team and a player who had developed a genuine connection with the city.
Their original demand of at least £100m was therefore understandable, even if Arsenal never appeared remotely interested in meeting it.
Arsenal’s opening offer was reportedly only £45m, which probably did little to improve relations between the clubs. Much of the subsequent negotiation was conducted through intermediary Kia Joorabchian rather than directly by sporting director Andrea Berta. Newcastle were frustrated by Arsenal’s apparent distance, while weeks passed without meaningful progress.
Arsenal were content to wait.
They knew Guimaraes wanted the move and believed Newcastle’s position would eventually soften as the end of the transfer window approached. The player had made it clear that he wanted to work with Arteta and personal terms were never a problem.
After the departures of Sandro Tonali to Tottenham and Anthony Gordon to Barcelona, Newcastle had been determined to retain their captain. However, Guimaraes’ desire to leave gradually made that position untenable.
Once he travelled directly to Spain rather than returning to England before Newcastle’s training camp, the transfer entered its decisive phase. A senior Newcastle executive finally contacted an Arsenal counterpart directly in an attempt to bring an end to what one source described as the “melodrama”.
Arsenal hoped to complete the deal for approximately £65m. Newcastle insisted £75m was the minimum acceptable figure. Eventually, the champions paid it.
For Arsenal, this is an outstanding signing.
Guimaraes can operate as either a No 6 or No 8, giving Arteta numerous midfield combinations. He is press-resistant, aggressive and capable of advancing the ball through both his passing and movement. He also possesses the slightly nasty competitive streak that every successful team needs.
Declan Rice apparently welcomed him with the message: “Come here and please no more fights, now we’re friends.”
That rather neatly captures why opposing supporters frequently dislike Guimaraes while wishing he played for their own team.
At 28—he turns 29 in November—the Brazilian sits outside Arsenal’s usual recruitment profile. That should not be considered a serious concern. Arsenal are no longer assembling a young team in the hope that it might eventually challenge for the title. They are Premier League champions attempting to remain champions.
There comes a point when potential has to be supplemented by experience, authority and players ready to deliver immediately.
The departures of Leandro Trossard and Christian Norgaard have also reduced the age of the squad. Gabriel Jesus remains available for transfer, while Mikel Merino, at 30, is currently Arsenal’s oldest outfield player. The squad can comfortably absorb an experienced midfielder at the peak of his career.
Indeed, Guimaraes may be precisely what Arsenal need.
The question is where everybody else fits.
Arteta now has an embarrassment of riches in central midfield. Rice, Guimaraes, Martin Odegaard, Martin Zubimendi, Merino and several younger options cannot all expect to start regularly.
Rice and Guimaraes could form a formidable partnership, with either capable of playing deeper or pushing forward. Guimaraes could also operate alongside Zubimendi, allowing Rice to take up the more advanced position in which he has become increasingly influential.
On paper, the possibilities are glorious. In practice, somebody is likely to find himself spending more time on the substitutes’ bench than expected.
That brings us to Zubimendi.
Reports continue to suggest that the Spaniard is homesick and open to returning to La Liga. His first season at Arsenal has not been a failure, but the arrival of Guimaraes inevitably raises further questions about his role.
Arsenal are unlikely to have invested £75m in Newcastle’s captain merely to improve the quality of their substitutes. Nor is Rice going anywhere. If Arteta intends to retain Odegaard as his principal creative midfielder, Zubimendi may suddenly find himself squeezed out of the preferred XI.
Perhaps Arteta wants genuine competition in every position. Perhaps he envisages rotating his midfield according to the opposition. Perhaps Zubimendi will adapt, flourish and make any discussion of a return to Spain irrelevant.
But the Guimaraes deal changes the equation.
For Newcastle, his departure closes the most significant chapter of their recent history. Guimaraes was visibly emotional when saying goodbye to his team-mates and staff, and nobody at the club has questioned his professionalism. Nevertheless, there is no disguising the scale of the loss.
New head coach Matthias Jaissle at least has £75m to reinvest and several weeks in which to do it. That is preferable to beginning the season with an unsettled captain or becoming trapped in the type of final-week scramble that followed Alexander Isak’s departure for Liverpool.
For Arsenal, this is another demonstration of their new status.
They once decided Bruno Guimaraes was not quite right for them. Four and a half years later, having watched him become one of the Premier League’s finest midfielders, they have paid £75m to bring him to the Emirates.
First impressions are not always final ones.
Guimaraes is finally an Arsenal player. The next question is whether his arrival will send Zubimendi back to Spain.