Upgrade Xhaka Don’t Give It To Ya?

A Gooner's Perspective: In Mikel We Trust!

Five months into his Arsenal tenure, Mikel Merino is already under the microscope. Tasked with filling Granit Xhaka's boots, the Spaniard has become a lightning rod for criticism, especially after the 1-1 draw at Brighton. Despite assisting Ethan Nwaneri's goal, fans took to social media to voice their frustrations over his performance.

The left-sided midfield position has been a conundrum since Xhaka's departure to Bayer Leverkusen in 2023. Kai Havertz was initially slotted in but later moved up front. Declan Rice briefly occupied the role with success, but the summer signing of Merino was seen as the long-term solution.

Merino arrived with a reputation as a 'duel monster,' having won more duels than any other player in Europe's top five leagues during his time at Real Sociedad. Statistics show he's living up to that hype, leading the squad in tackles in the final third, aerial duels, and blocks per 90 minutes. Yet, it's his on-ball contributions that have fans concerned.

Lacking the sharpness and fluidity expected, Merino's progressive passing stats lag behind his midfield partners. This could be attributed to a disrupted pre-season and a shoulder injury that delayed his debut until October. Or perhaps fans need to accept a good team is made up of various types of players, who all contribute in different ways. 

At least, Mikel Arteta acknowledges Merino's strengths lie in physicality and duel-winning rather than playmaking.

Some supporters argue that Arsenal should have pursued a more creative midfielder, like Crystal Palace's Eberechi Eze, to address the team's attacking struggles. However, Arteta remains confident in Merino's suitability for the squad's needs.

As the season progresses, the question remains: Will Merino silence the doubters, or will the Gunners rue not opting for a more creative force in midfield?

Toon Army's Take: Been There, Done That

Arsenal's acquisition of Mikel Merino has raised eyebrows among Newcastle United supporters. The midfielder's stint at St. James' Park during the 2017/18 season was underwhelming, leading to his departure and subsequent resurgence at Real Sociedad. Now, as he faces criticism from Arsenal fans, the Toon Army can't help but feel a sense of déjà vu.

Merino's physicality and duel-winning abilities were evident during his time on Tyneside, but questions about his consistency and adaptability lingered. His current struggles at Arsenal, particularly in contributing to the team's attacking play, echo the concerns Newcastle fans had years ago.

While some Gooners are already calling for a more creative midfield presence, Newcastle supporters watch with a mix of amusement and vindication. They've seen this story unfold before and are curious to see if Merino can finally prove his doubters wrong or if history will repeat itself in north London.

If you don't believe just watch him score the winner against the Magpies!